I watch 99% of my YouTube videos on my Apple TV. My interests vary, but because their recommendation system seems to think that 1 video about 3D printing means I suddenly want to watch 50 videos on the subject, I spend a great deal of time telling the system that I’m not interested in a video.
On the Apple TV app, this process is already kinda broken inasmuch as I have to provide a reason where the only two choices are “I’ve already watched the video” or “I don’t like the video”. On the web, a reason isn’t required. Do I really not like a video? Or is it simply not relevant to my interests? Am I going to subdue recommendations from a channel I might like simply because I “don’t like” a single video? All of this is opaque to the end user, so there are occasions where I simply select “I’ve already watched the video” just to make it go away.
Today I saw a new option for the first time - on its own row in the interface, a single video displayed. I’ve watched a number of videos from this channel before - one guy riding his bikes around Michigan. But this particular video was about some type of camp stove. On this single row in the app was the heading “Help us improve YouTube”, and beside the thumbnail is the question “Is this a good recommendation for you?” My options are “Not now”, “No”, and “Yes”. I’m certain “Yes” will increase recommendations of similar videos (though YouTube’s definition of “similar” is already questionable - IYKYK). “Not now” dismisses the whole question. But “No”? Selecting “No” displays a new panel with the heading “Why is it a very bad recommendation?”
Wait, what now? How come “no” assumes this is a “very bad” recommendation instead simply “not good”? As if that wasn’t a poor place to start, my choices range from the vague to the horrible:
- Not interested
- Violent or disgusting
- Overly sexual
- Trashy
- Misleading
- Upsetting
- Other
What the heck!? I just don’t care about a camp stove, I’m not offended! I suppose “Not interested” is the safest answer here, but I still question the notion that this is a “very bad recommendation” for me just because I said it isn’t good, and I worry that any answer would have undesirable effects.